The book attempts to throw some light on the cause of the rift, between the sunni and shia branches of islam. Why we need to read after the prophet amidst todays shiasunni. Dec 04, 2017 what most people will tell you is that the shia sunni divide began as a political disagreement, which took theological implications later. Although ignorant and intolerant people are found on both sides of the fence, shias being a minority in most places are usually more knowledgeable about their faith, even i. In this gripping narrative history, lesley hazleton tells the tragic story at the heart of the ongoing rivalry between the sunni and shia branches of islam, a rift that dominates the news now more than ever. This article compares the similarities and differences between the two. Timely and provocative, sunnis and shia provides needed perspective on the historical roots of todays conflicts and reveals how both branches of islam have influenced and emulated each other in unexpected ways. Shia sunni conflicts are raging in syria, iraq, lebanon and pakistan and the divide is growing deeper across the muslim world. Starting in arabia in the year 632 and reaching its terrible breaking point fifty years later in iraq, it still shapes modern headlines from irans islamic revolution to. This historical schism continues to permeate the daily lives of. Vali nasr is a widely respected scholar who claims expertise in multiple fields that pertain to middle eastern and south. However, akhbaris reject ijma and aql thus rejecting ijtihad. Feb 12, 2007 the following is a list of suggested reading about the shiite sunni conflict. In this edition, page numbers are just like the physical edition.
Even as muhammad lay dying, the battle over who would take control of the new islamic nation had begun, beginning a succession crisis marked by power grabs, assassination, political intri. While it is clear that the shias fall on one side of the political divide and that they are generally opposed by the sunni arab nationalists and sunni arab monarchists, the sectarian divisions become blurred when considering sunni islamists. Within the sunni and shia branches, you can also find a number of sects. At lower levels, nonstate groups like the islamic state and hezbollah are fighting each other in ways that cross state lines in places like lebanon, iraq, and syria. Shia and sunni islam are the two major denominations of islam. The sunnishia split has its roots in disagreements over authority after the death of the prophet mohammed in the seventh century. Shiite sunni conflicts are raging in syria, iraq, lebanon and pakistan and the divide is growing deeper across the muslim world.
This is the foundation story of the shiasunni split in islam, a magnificent tale of power, intrigue, assassination, and passionate faith. The conflicts in iraq and syria are also show a divide between the two, as many sunni men have joined rebel groups, while men from the shia community are most often fighting for or with government. Where shia muslims do not allow quran abrogation, wahabis. When prophet muhammad was breathing his last, the tussle over power had already begun. Why we need to read after the prophet amidst todays shiasunni divide. The conflicts between shia and sunni muslims go back to the 7th century and the death of the prophet muhammad.
To see more differences in shia and sunni hadith collections, visit this wikipedia category and its subcategories. Feb 15, 2007 iraq war deepens sunni shia divide when the united states invaded iraq four years ago, it didnt set out to deepen the sunni shia divide in the islamic world. The epic story of the shiasunni split in islam is available in paperback. The arab uprisings and the rebirth of the shiasunni divide v ms. A dispute over succession to islamic prophet muhammad as a caliph of the islamic community spread across various parts of the world, which led to the battle of jamal and battle of siffin. The myth and history of sunnishia divide december 23, 2016 0 274 amir ahmadi arian head of the shiite opposition, left, and sunni muslim leader of a liberal opposition party, right, hold a sign reading no sunni, no shia. Today, the sunnishia divide and the future of islam. Vali nasr is a widely respected scholar who claims expertise in multiple fields that pertain to middle eastern and south asian politics, particularly sunnishia relations. An iranian flag flies at the sorough oil field in 2005. The differences between shia and sunni muslims business. Saudis use the 6 sahih hadith book, not the really the 4 sunni schools of jurisprudence, and while wahabism is similar to the sunni hanbali school, ahmad ibn hanbals musnad is not the hadith collection used. After the prophet is a remarkable telling of the story of islamparticularly the ongoing rivalry between the sunni and shia branches of islam. This video is part of the council on foreign relations infoguide presentation, the sunnishia divide.
Similarly, in shiitism, the druze are a somewhat eclectic sect residing in lebanon, syria, and israel. Likewise, sunnis reject shia islams the four books to see more differences in shia and sunni hadith collections, visit this wikipedia category and its subcategories day of ashura holiday. Moreover, the book is written with great understanding and sympathy. Journalist lesley hazleton describes, in this book, the origins of the shiasunni split in islam a rift that began when the prophet muhammad died without sons. Aug 19, 2009 the division between sunnis and shia is the largest and oldest in the history of islam. Iraq war deepens sunnishia divide when the united states invaded iraq four years ago, it didnt set out to deepen the sunnishia divide in the islamic world. Raheb homavandireuters a new book on the sunnishia conflict makes clear that the steady radicalization of sectarian difference in the. The famous shia book alghadir by allameh amini is a collection of evidences and proofs for ghadir events written after referring to 100,000 sunni books and full reading of 10,000. In many countries it has become common for members of the two sects to intermarry and pray at the same mosques.
May 23, 2017 shia sunni conflicts are raging in syria, iraq, lebanon and pakistan and the divide is growing deeper across the muslim world. Religious law muftis judges traditionally administered religious law based on one of the 4. Vali nasr the sunnishia divide and the future of islam. In this gripping narrative history, lesley hazleton tells the tr. The book of roughly 200 pages is clearly divided into 3 parts and.
This compelling and accessible book also examines the diverse regional contexts of the sunnishia divide, examining how it has. The reality is that the shia sunni divide was caused by a theological and po. This week two shia activists in the gulf states have been stripped of their citizenships, sparking claims of discrimination and pointing to growing tensions between sunni and shia. Sectarian conflict is becoming entrenched in a growing number of muslim countries and is threatening to fracture iraq and syria. The history of the sunni and shia split traces the origins of the split and the historic effects of the main divide within islam. Although the majority of muslims remain faithful to the sunni sect of islam, approximately 15 percent subscribe to the shi. Jul 15, 2014 sunni and shia muslims have lived peacefully together for centuries. The heirs of the prophet by barnaby rogerson goes back to analyze the most basic division and its roots from the first generation of muslims. The divisions date back to the years immediately after the prophet mohammeds death. These disagreements about the nature of an ideal muslim leader eventually created two. Differences between sunni, shia and ibadi islam wikipedia. What is the problem between shia and sunni muslims. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Shia islam rejects sunni islams kutub alsittah, or the five allegedly original hadiths, and rejects hadiths attributed to muhammads wife, aisha, who shias feel defied ali.
September 29, 2006 the conflict between sunnis and shiites goes back nearly 1,400 years and today, it is tearing iraq apart. How conflicts within islam will shape the future, by vali nasr, w. These disagreements about the nature of an ideal muslim leader eventually created two distinct and dominant sects of islam. It also goes into some detail about sunni shia relations. Apr 23, 2019 sunni and shia muslims share the most fundamental islamic beliefs and articles of faith and are the two main subgroups in islam. Jul 31, 2019 the sunni shia divide into the 21st century in addition to karbala, the npr podcast throughline identified three key milestones that would sharpen sunni shia divisions by the end of the 20th century. The conflicts in iraq and syria are also show a divide between the two, as many sunni men have joined rebel groups, while men from the shia community. Tensions between sunnis and shias, exploited by regional rivals.
Sunni and shia muslims have lived peacefully together for centuries. Whether or not george bush even knew there were such things as shias and sunnis before invading iraq, after reading lesley hazletons gripping book no one. The book does an excellent job of going into the history of both groups and exactly what led to the split. They do differ, however, and that separation stemmed initially, not from spiritual distinctions, but political ones. Council on foreign relations interactive guide to the sunnishiite divide. Religious law muftis judges traditionally administered religious law based on one of the 4 schools of law.
Mar 18, 2020 the sunnishite divide occurred in 632 a. John mchugos work looks beyond lazy punditry on the sunnishia divide to take us on a journey of islamic history and coexistence. Paradox and power in the islamic republic, by ray takeyh, times books, 2006. Shiasunni conflicts are raging in syria, iraq, lebanon and pakistan and the divide is growing deeper across the muslim world. The shia revival by vali nasr is a good book on modern shia political power. Along with pictures of important people, places, and events, you will learn about the history of the sunnis and shias like never before, in no time at all. Sunni muslims agree with the position taken by many of the prophets companions, that the new leader should be elected from among those capable of the job. The book is well narrated, good for basic knowledge of shia sunni split, but dont take every line of the book as a final word, for every incident there are numerous interpretations, so try to read more, but one can start from this. They chose sides following the death of the islamic prophet muhammad in ad 632. Shiitesunni conflicts are raging in syria, iraq, lebanon and pakistan and the divide is growing deeper across the muslim world. The conflict between sunnis and shias is the news of everyday, but there has. The sunnishia divide into the 21st century in addition to karbala, the npr podcast throughline identified three key milestones that would sharpen. How conflicts within islam will shape the future 2006, vali nasr addresses an issue that is gaining increased importance in the contemporary coverage of global islam. The dispute intensified greatly after the battle of karbala, in.
The division between shia and sunni dates back to the death of the prophet muhammad, and the question of who was to take over the leadership of the muslim nation. For example, in saudi arabia, sunni wahhabism is a prevalent and puritanical faction. It has to do with what is perceived as the growing role being played by arab shia who many see is making a radical break with a long tradition of political inactivity. The following is a list of suggested reading about the shiitesunni conflict. What most people will tell you is that the shia sunni divide began as a political disagreement, which took theological implications later.
The epic story of the shiasunni split in islam by lesley hazleton 2010, paperback at the best online prices at ebay. Oct 04, 2015 the conflicts in iraq and syria are also show a divide between the two, as many sunni men have joined rebel groups, while men from the shia community are most often fighting for or with government. The sunnishia divide into the 21st century in addition to karbala, the npr podcast throughline identified three key milestones that would sharpen sunni shia divisions by the end of the 20th century. Likewise, sunnis reject shia islams the four books. The intermittent conflict between the shias and sunnis in iraq and.
Its a tale of power, intrigue, rivalry, jealousy, politics, faith and human emotions told in a wonderfully novelistic style. Sep 22, 2010 this week two shia activists in the gulf states have been stripped of their citizenships, sparking claims of discrimination and pointing to growing tensions between sunni and shia. The religious divide is perhaps the most important fault line in the turbulent middle east today, with sunni nations like egypt and saudi arabia at odds with shiite nations like iran. What are some good and reliable books on shiasunni divide. Where shia muslims do not allow quran abrogation, wahabis use the 6 sahih books for islamic law. Shia hadiths differ from sunni hadiths mainly in that shia hadiths include the sayings of the ahlul bayt. The epic story of the shiasunni split in islam ebook. The problem is ignorance, not the fact that these 2 thoughtgroups exist. Sunni in arabic means one who follows the traditions of the prophet. Dec 23, 2016 the myth and history of sunnishia divide december 23, 2016 0 274 amir ahmadi arian head of the shiite opposition, left, and sunni muslim leader of a liberal opposition party, right, hold a sign reading no sunni, no shia. Sunnis believed that the new leader should be elected. It also goes into some detail about sunnishia relations. Jan 19, 2018 the sunnishiite schism also provokes violence between muslims in such. The division between sunnis and shia is the largest and oldest in the history of islam.
525 1538 1464 210 101 1563 941 918 354 1004 797 807 1143 1515 1125 594 1435 66 154 115 231 1032 1337 561 1382 996 305 329 973 528 1207 1202 81 1104 300